Below is a list of all the past NAGAAA Cup winners for each division.
| YEAR | HOST CITY | DIVISION | TEAM |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2023 | Salt Lake City, UT | A | Atlanta ATX Reign– Champions |
| A | Dallas Texas Force– 2nd | ||
| A | San Francisco Fury Unleashed– 3rd | ||
| B | South Florida United– Champions | ||
| B | San Francisco Sharks– 2nd | ||
| B | Palm Springs Boozehounds– 3rd | ||
| Masters C | Palm Springs Past Our Prime– Champions | ||
| Masters C | Palm Springs Greyhounds– 2nd | ||
| Masters C | Chicago Legends– 3rd | ||
| Masters D | Los Angles Thunderbirds– Champions | ||
| Masters D | San Diego Rebels– 2nd | ||
| Masters D | Phoenix Charlie’s Foxxxes– 3rd | ||
| 2022 | Richmond, VA | A | Palm Springs Rounders 2.0 – Champions |
| A | San Francisco Fury Unleashed – 2nd | ||
| A | Texas Force – 3rd | ||
| B | Washington D.C. Rockets – Champions | ||
| B | Atlanta Primetime Elite – 2nd | ||
| B | Phoenix Zona – 3rd | ||
| 2021 | Palm Springs, CA | A | Phoenix Arizona Toros – Champions |
| A | Phoenix Charlie’s – 2nd | ||
| A | Orlando Unicorns A – 3rd | ||
| B | Atlanta Primetime Elite – Champions | ||
| B | Austin ATX Fusion – 2nd | ||
| B | Orlando Unicorns B – 3rd | ||
| 2019 | Denver, CO | A | Palm Springs 2.0 – Champions |
| A | Phoenix Charlie’s – 2nd | ||
| A | Orlando Unicorns A – 3rd | ||
| B | Atlanta Primetime Elite – Champions | ||
| B | Austin ATX Fusion – 2nd | ||
| B | Orlando Unicorns B – 3rd | ||
| 2018 | Minneapolis, MN | A | Phoenix Arizona Toros – Champions |
| A | Dallas Texas Force – 2nd | ||
| A | Palm Springs Rounders 2.0 – 3rd | ||
| B | Dallas Lone Star Smash – Champions | ||
| B | San Francisco Quake – 2nd | ||
| B | Seattle Los Gallitos – 3rd | ||
| 2017 | Columbus, OH | A | Palm Springs Rounders 2.0 – Champions |
| A | Orlando Unicorns – 2nd | ||
| A | Atlanta Elite – 3rd | ||
| B | Knoxville Cyclones – Champions | ||
| B | Atlanta Showstoppers – 2nd | ||
| B | San Francisco Quake – 3rd | ||
| 2016 | Dallas, TX | A | Atlanta Elite – Champions |
| A | Texas Force (powered by Dallas Woody’s) – 2nd | ||
| A | Palm Springs Rounders 2.0 – 3rd | ||
| B | Austin Hot Flash – Champions | ||
| B | Orlando Unicorns – 2nd | ||
| B | Dallas Toxic – 3rd | ||
| 2015 | Phoenix, AZ | A | Palm Springs Rounders 2.0 – Champions |
| A | Houston Force – 2nd | ||
| A | Phoenix Toros – 3rd | ||
| B | Orlando Voltage – Champions | ||
| B | Tulsa Smoke – 2nd | ||
| B | Phoenix Ice – 3rd | ||
| 2014 | Phoenix, AZ | A | Roscoes Coors Light HP2 Ticoz Monsta Toros – Champions |
| A | Palm Springs Rounders 2.0 – 2nd | ||
| A | Orlando Force – 3rd |